What is job insecurity?
Job insecurity refers to the perceived uncertainty about employment continuity or about conditions considered important, such as job duties, working hours, or workplace. It should not be confused with a lack of physical safety in a facility. Here, the term is used in its psychosocial sense, related to employment.
The contractual situation provides information, but it doesn’t explain the whole picture. Significant uncertainties can exist during a reorganization even with an open-ended contract. There can also be important differences between individuals with the same type of contract depending on the information they receive, the predictability of decisions, and their working environment.
Continuity and conditions of employment
It’s important to distinguish between concerns about losing one’s job and concerns about changes in job characteristics. This distinction helps to understand what information is missing and what organizational decisions are pending. Lumping all situations together in a single, generic question can hinder the selection of appropriate preventive measures.
The analysis does not aim to calculate individual probabilities of layoffs or make promises of stability that the organization cannot sustain. It seeks to identify sources of uncertainty, how they are communicated, and what conditions can be improved. Credibility is important: an honest explanation of what is known and what remains to be done is more useful than an unfounded guarantee.
Organizational factors that exacerbate uncertainty
Persistent rumors, conflicting messages, and changes without clear criteria can increase anxiety. So can uncertainty about who will provide information or when a relevant decision will be made. Conflict and role ambiguity can compound the problem when reorganization alters functions without clarifying responsibilities.
The INSST includes job insecurity among the conditions that must be considered in psychosocial analysis. Its management requires attention to the specific context. It is not enough to assume that all uncertainty stems from the market or that nothing can be done within the company, because the way planning and communication are implemented also influences the work experience.
Exposure assessment
Psychosocial assessment should identify groups and periods of greater uncertainty without requiring each individual to disclose unnecessary private information. Anticipated changes, communication, roles, and perceptions of predictability can be analyzed using appropriate instruments and complementary techniques.
It is important to explain why the responses are being collected and how they will be protected. During a reorganization, there may be fear that expressing concerns will affect employment decisions. The results should be used to improve conditions, presented in aggregate form, and kept separate from individual performance reviews or personnel selection processes.
Information and participation during the changes
The HSE guidelines on organizational changes emphasize timely communication, consultation, and explanation of their potential impact on work. A practical application involves distinguishing between decisions already made, open proposals, and issues that remain unclear. It is also important to identify who will answer questions and when updates will be available.
Participation must have a real and clearly explained scope. Asking about matters that have already been settled without prior notice can erode trust. When tasks are modified, preparation must include sufficient information, training, and support for the new procedures. These preventive measures do not replace applicable employment-law procedures or information and consultation obligations.
Practical example
In a hypothetical example, an organisation announces the integration of two departments. For several weeks, it fails to explain how responsibilities will be distributed, and different managers offer conflicting explanations. Employees begin taking on additional tasks to prove their worth, even though no one has defined which work should be prioritized.
Management publishes a decision timeline, consolidates information, and clarifies provisional roles. Regarding outstanding issues, it avoids promising results that are not yet known. A consultation channel is established, and workloads are reviewed during the transition. This intervention reduces manageable uncertainties, although it cannot eliminate all elements associated with the change.
Monitoring and support
Monitoring can verify whether updates arrive on schedule, whether questions are answered, and whether management communicates consistently. It should also review for overloads or changes in organizational behavior that may accompany uncertainty, such as extended workdays or competition for tasks without a real need.
Individual support resources can be helpful when someone needs assistance, but they are not a substitute for clear information and informed decisions. The relationship with work-related stress should be analysed without automatically labeling concerns as diagnoses. When appropriate, healthcare intervention requires competent professionals and the confidentiality and other safeguards applicable to health information.
Common mistakes and limitations
Common mistakes include downplaying concerns, communicating solely through rumors, or assuring stability without sufficient basis. It is also a mistake to use psychosocial assessments to identify individuals considered less adaptable. This practice contradicts their preventive purpose and can prevent the communication of genuine difficulties.
The goal is to improve predictability, decision consistency, and support during transitions. Prevention does not guarantee a specific contractual outcome nor does it replace employment advice on an individual situation. It does, however, allow for action on a significant portion of the conditions under which people experience and implement organizational change.
Prolonged uncertainty and health: interpreting evidence without diagnosing
Perceived insecurity deserves attention even before a dismissal decision exists. To examine exposure, distinguish what people fear losing, how long uncertainty lasts, what information is available and how much influence they have over relevant conditions. Concerns about income, duties or location can coexist with overload, limited support or role conflict. That combination calls for assessment of work, rather than an explanation based solely on personality or a requirement for individuals to demonstrate illness before they are heard. The question is which conditions can be understood and improved through prevention.
Ferrie and colleagues’ 2002 prospective Whitehall II study examined British office-based civil servants. Its abstract reports higher self-reported morbidity with sustained insecurity or loss of security, while physiological changes were limited. This provides evidence of association in a specific population and period; it cannot attribute an individual illness to uncertainty or justify extrapolation to every sector.
A cautious preventive application collects information about conditions: repeated unanswered questions, tasks accepted to avoid appearing dispensable, unpredictable shift changes or difficulty raising concerns. Symptoms require professional attention when appropriate and must not be dismissed as “just nerves”. Operational managers need organisational measures, without access to diagnoses. Nor should they infer good health from low sickness absence: during a transition, fewer recorded absences may coexist with fear of taking leave. Follow-up combines exposure information with how work operates, using aggregated health data only where their use is lawful and appropriate. Individual healthcare and organisational action remain distinct, complementary responsibilities.
Contractual precarity: examine conditions rather than label people
Temporary employment, perceived insecurity and precarity are not interchangeable terms. A temporary contract describes duration, but preventive analysis also needs to examine predictable schedules, remuneration, access to training, participation, support and continuity of tasks. An open-ended contract does not remove uncertainty during restructuring either. WHO and Spain’s INSST identify job insecurity and certain organisational conditions as relevant to mental health and psychosocial analysis. A contract type must not be taken to determine a disorder on its own. Assessment should examine what people actually experience in their work and the resources available to them.
Conditions can be compared between groups when group size and confidentiality safeguards permit. Check whether recently recruited staff receive timely information, know whom to consult and are prepared for the tasks actually assigned. Where turnover is frequent, repeating a generic presentation does not guarantee learning or coordination. Job changes, allocation of less desirable tasks and the practical ability to report risks also need review. A voluntary survey receiving no responses does not establish that a group has no problems. Participation barriers, including access to the survey during different shifts, should be considered.
Intervention should address what the organisation can change: advance scheduling, clear criteria, information, mentoring, resources and continuity of prevention between recruitment rounds. Article 19 of Spain’s Occupational Risk Prevention Law requires sufficient, appropriate safety training regardless of the contract’s form or duration. Workers must not bear its cost. Improving those conditions does not replace compliance with employment legislation or turn a wellbeing programme into compensation for employment irregularities. Preventive assessment and advice about individual employment rights have complementary functions and should remain identifiable, with concerns directed to the appropriate competent people.
Automation and AI: separate technical exposure, decisions and expectations
News about a technology’s capabilities does not constitute an employer’s decision about jobs. The JRC distinguishes occupational exposure, meaning overlap between technical capabilities and tasks, from actual deployment. An AI exposure index therefore cannot be read as an individual probability of dismissal. Communication should explain which system is being tested, which tasks might change and which decisions remain open, without presenting a general forecast as something that has already happened within the organisation.
Fear can increase when savings are announced without explaining remaining workload, responsibilities or training. Before implementing change, identify tasks that disappear, others that expand and new checking obligations. A team may need less time to produce a draft and more time to verify it; theoretical savings should not automatically be treated as spare capacity for higher targets. People must be able to report errors, difficulties and unexpected uses without psychosocial assessment becoming a selection exercise favouring those who appear most enthusiastic about technology. Actual task demands matter more than promotional descriptions of potential efficiency.
Prevention belongs within risk assessment when working conditions change, with information, consultation and appropriate training under the applicable framework. A transition period with responsible people, learning time and workload review can help, without promising contractual stability that nobody can guarantee. Training must not be treated as proof that anyone who remains concerned is unable to adapt. Follow-up examines whether new functions are understood, resources are sufficient and issues are resolved, distinguishing technical difficulty from concern about employment. Message analysis or an automated score does not replace that discussion and competent assessment of the conditions involved.
Youth underemployment, skill mismatch and career expectations
When examining underemployment, specify the actual problem. Working fewer hours than desired and available is different from performing tasks below one’s qualification level, receiving insufficient income or lacking development opportunities. These situations may overlap but need different measures. The ILO’s 2024 youth-employment summary shows that job quality, security and educational mismatch vary across contexts. Its global figures do not diagnose a Spanish workforce’s circumstances or justify attributing disorders to a generation. Definitions and population boundaries need to be clear before comparing findings or selecting an intervention.
Within an organisation, assessment should examine job demands and real opportunities for learning, participation and progression. Higher education does not automatically confer safety competence for any task, just as young workers do not need less protection because of their age. Induction should clarify duties, limits of responsibility and available support. Where promotion prospects are discussed, explain criteria and conditions without turning an aspiration into a promise. Dangerous tasks or excessive demands must not become an informal requirement for demonstrating commitment. Access to useful information should not depend on knowing whom to ask through personal contacts.
Measures may include reviewing job content, relevant training, accessible mentoring and transparent criteria for internal opportunities, according to identified needs. A course does not solve every situation: where the issue is insufficient predictable hours or income, the response should examine that condition. Follow-up must distinguish participation in an activity from actual improvement. Young people’s views should be incorporated without stereotypes about fragility or motivation, and results aggregated sufficiently to avoid identifying individuals in small teams or distinctive contracts. Reviewing outcomes with participants also helps establish whether an offered measure addressed the problem they raised.
An intervention plan and follow-up during transition
A useful plan defines which uncertainties can be managed, which decisions remain outstanding and who is responsible for each measure. In a hypothetical example, a service centre undergoing reorganisation identifies unequal information between shifts, duplicated tasks and uncertainty about training. Measures extend beyond a reassuring presentation: updates are made accessible across shifts, provisional duties are clarified and learning time is reserved. The timetable should also acknowledge what cannot yet be resolved. Participation becomes meaningful when people understand which proposals can influence decisions and receive a response to the points they raise.
HSE’s British technical guidance on change offers communication, consultation and support principles. In Spain, Articles 16, 18 and 19 of the Occupational Risk Prevention Law provide the framework for assessment, planning, information, participation and safety training. The plan assigns resources, responsibilities and deadlines and verifies implementation. Where reorganisation affects contractual relationships, the relevant employment procedures must follow their own route; a safety meeting does not replace them. Individual assistance can complement the process but cannot independently correct unpredictable schedules, conflicting messages or inadequate resources. Support should be connected to identified needs without transferring organisational responsibility to individuals.
Possible indicators include completed updates, outstanding questions, actual access to training and implementation of organisational adjustments. Interpret them alongside assessed exposure and workers’ views, avoiding targets such as “zero complaints” or individual rankings of resistance to change. Falling participation may reflect declining trust rather than improvement. Repeated assessment should document changes in workforce, tasks or method, so that different circumstances are not compared as equivalent. Closing a measure requires checking its effect and reviewing what remains unresolved, without guaranteeing the absence of uncertainty or a particular clinical outcome. The process should remain open to corrections when conditions change.
